Karen calls Tim and Sapphire back to Gunslinger Gulch to investigate a shocking, fire-branded omen; when Tim repels deeper into The Pit for answers, a confrontation with his own dark nemesis leads to painful revelations about the living and the dead.
Sarah Lemos brings disturbing visions of a nearby cave, while Sapphire uncovers a mysterious suicide connected to the Log Cabin; the team attempts to sever Karen from her traumatic past when a ring reveals a deceptive spirit is courting her.
Scott Di Lalla joins the fray as Tim and Sapphire use hypnosis to uncover secrets from the Broussard family's past, but a sinister spirit attachment hinders the experiment; frustrated, the team seeks out the darkness in two abandoned hospitals.
To convince his fractured team they are battling Beelzebub, Tim leads them to an epicenter of suffering, the Old Montana State Prison; the emotional experience pushes Tim to cross a dangerous line and summon the high-ranking demon.
The team splinters when Tim and Scott summon a demon despite Sarah and Sapphire's objections; when the experiment exposes a new threat directly tied to Karen, they must put their differences aside and fight the darkness together.
Tim and Sapphire help the Broussard family solve the haunting of Gunslinger Gulch.
Tim and Sapphire make connections between the bloody history of Anaconda, Montana, and Gunslinger Gulch; a trek into the hills in search of a mysterious pit has medium Sarah Lemos fearing for everyone's safety.
Tim uncovers a link between Gunslinger Gulch and a former brothel in Butte, Mont.; back at the ranch, the team grows more concerned for the Broussards after an experiment reveals a dark force's psychological warfare.
The team builds a psychomanteum, a dimly lit room of mirrors, to force a controlling entity to manifest inside the church; a psychic sketch artist reveals a dark secret, sending the Broussard family and the investigation, into fresh turmoil.
It's a showdown between good and evil at Gunslinger Gulch when the team invites a priest to the ranch to expel the dark entity.