Baking duos must create a cake topper that showcases a city of love; bakers must create a dream wedding cake for Andrea and Jered, a couple of professional puppeteers who want a blend of a traditional design for her and a puppet theme for him.
Five baking teams must make a cake topper that's an ode to music; the teams meet their clients, Ashley and Phil, who got engaged while dancing.
The first challenge for the four remaining teams is to create cake toppers that pay homage to online dating; the bakers must blend the different styles of a couple, Stephanie and Stephanie, and must use peanut butter and chocolate in their cakes.
Six of America's best baking duos begin their journey to becoming wedding cake champions; the bakers are challenged to create an outrageous dress cake topper and a dream wedding cake combining traditional design with a superhero theme.
Tara Lipinski's dog Dublin joins the four remaining teams to introduce a precocious pet topper challenge; Johnny Weir and Tara introduce Brandon and Matthew, who ask the bakers to combine Brandon's love of nature with Matthew's love of the city.
The final three teams must make a first-anniversary celebration cake for Tara Lipinski and her husband, Todd Kapostasy; the couple wants to capture all of their travels on one cake, plus they have an untimely surprise for the competitors.